WooCommerce Order Search Field Not Rendering All Orders

I am using Algolia on two websites, but one continues to have the same recurring issue. Older orders successfully pull up in the WooCommerce Order Search Field, but newer orders won’t. I’ve attempted to reindex the orders multiple times, but I continue to get an error message when I do. I’ve even tried to change the reindex file name and order count, but it still gives me an error.

I have Algolia Version: 1.13.2, WooCommerce version Version 5.9.0 and Wordpress version Version 5.8.2. (This is the same for what I am using on my other website, too, which is operating normally.)